Ryan Beasley Law

Schedule Your Confidential Consultation 864-991-3379

Can you record the police? Yes, but there are limits.

Law enforcement has historically clashed with journalists who are recording live events. Sometimes reporters had their cameras taken away or their film destroyed.

In the smartphone era, regular citizens find themselves in confrontations with police over videos. What are your rights regarding filming the police? Can you secretly record law enforcement? Can they confiscate your phone?

 

Know your rights when recording police

It is not illegal to record police in a public place or to record your own encounter such as a traffic stop. You do not need the consent of police.

But some officers have different ideas. They may tell you to stop recording. They may demand you erase the photos or video. In the most extreme cases, they might confiscate your phone, delete images or arrest you.

U.S. courts have consistently upheld the rights of citizens to record police, as a First Amendment right and as a necessary check against abuse of power. There may be immediate consequences – such as being handcuffed or having your phone taken -- but ultimately the law is on your side.

There are some limitations and consequences

In general, citizens may not interfere with police in the performance of their duties. Getting too close with a camera or shouting in an officer’s face may cross the line. If filming the action puts you in harm’s way or endangers the officer’s safety, you may lose your legal protection or officers may lose their patience. Live streaming events – such as a police raid – could compromise law enforcement by tipping off the suspects.

Conceivably, you could face criminal charges of disorderly conduct, assault on a police officer, or obstruction of justice. In the eyes of the court, police may also be justified in these situations in using physical force to disrupt a recording or to remove the person.

There is also some question as to whether you can secretly record police. If you are filming an altercation or police misconduct, there are reasons to do it discreetly -- namely to avoid having your video confiscated or destroyed by an angry cop. South Carolina is a one-party consent state for recording conversations. This means you can secretly record a phone call if you are one of the parties in the conversation, but you could not secretly record someone else’s conversation.

So what about secretly filming police in action? A federal judge in Massachusetts recently sided with citizens in this situation, saying that the state’s wiretap law did not apply. It’s a gray area of the law that has not yet filtered its way to the higher courts. Citizens could be detained or land in legal jeopardy by taping police without their knowledge. But some people feel that keeping the police accountable is worth the price.

 

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Awards & Accolades Over my career, I have earned a number of honors reflecting my professionalism and commitment to my clients. These awards include:

  • 10 best 2016 client satisfaction American institute of personal injury attorneys | Ryan L. Beasley Has Been Nominated and Accepted as a 2016 AIOPIA’S 10 Best in South Carolina For Client Satisfaction
  • 10 best 2016 client satisfaction American institute of criminal law attorneys | Ryan L. Beasley Has Been Nominated and Accepted as a 2016 AIOCLA’S 10 Best in South Carolina For Client Satisfaction
  • rated by super lawyers ryan l. beasley superlawyers.com
  • legal elite of the upstate 2013-2015
  • nationally ranked superior dui attorney by the nafdd 2013
  • Recognized as one of the top 75 DUI Attorneys in South Carolina by the National Advocacy for DUI Defense, LLC (NAFDD) 2013

  • america's most honored professionals ryan l. beasley
  • greenville business magazine 2015 legal elite of the upstate greenville's top attorneys
  • The National Trial Lawyers | Top 100 Trial Lawyers
  • The National Trial Lawyers | Top 40 Under 40
  • AV | Preeminent | Peer Rated for Highest Level of Professional Excellence | 2018
  • client distinction award
  • Top Young Attorneys 2014 Rising stars selected by peer recognition and professional Achievement
  • national academy of criminal defense attorneys